After a not so lengthy hiatus from speaking about jpop, and jpop adjoining teams I’m again with ME:I’s solely barely youthful sister group IS:SUE. Constructed with 4 contestants from Produce 101 Japan the Women, who simply all barely missed the minimize off for his or her older sister’s group. We’re in fact going to cowl IS:SUE this time round!
The members of IS:SUE did take part in Produce 101, all them them rating simply outdoors of debut vary. To get the bias out of the way in which, I hoped that Sakaguchi Rino and Kenmotsu Nano would have made the ultimate line-up. Rino’s vocals aren’t any joke, and he or she has a ton of charisma on stage. Nano is an precise all-arounder when it got here to performances. No matter my emotions, it was price noting that each one 4 have been noticeably absent on social media submit PD 101. Particularly since that they had all ranked extremely excessive, which means they may simply launch tremendous profitable profiles with a little bit of effort. All 4 briefly did have SNS profiles, thanking followers for his or her assist, after which deleting stated profiles in very early 2024.
It wasn’t lengthy that it was made public that LAPONE GIRLS was a brand new division below LAPONE, and that that they had taken on a number of ladies as trainees. They have been initially teased as “New Woman is Coming” on March twenty ninth 2024. On April twenty fourth, a bit below a month later, IS:SUE was formally a unit. It was determined that they’d debut June nineteenth 2024.
Backside Row L to R: Nano, Rin.
Which was a really daring alternative on LAPONE/LAPONE GIRLS half as an organization, the brief recreation was iffy however the lengthy recreation I believe it was the proper alternative. As a result of IS:SUE, not even having debuted but, have been already cornering followers’ consideration. Many YOU:ME’s have been perplexed by administration’s decisions. That they had, myself included, assumed the brand new unit would debut (a lot) in a while like their male counter elements. To followers shock, the flip round could be a mere two months after ME:I that IS:SUE would debut.
There have been quite a lot of opinions, each constructive and damaging, as extra information got here out. As somebody who was mildly impressed that LAPONE wasn’t locking the group within the basement (an extended held follow in Kpop) – it was the proper transfer. A bit stunning, however in the end the higher transfer. IS:SUE had educated simply so long as ME:I, so coaching them much more could be a waste of assets. Ready for much longer then a June debut, would have simply run down their PD 101 recognition and public relevancy. LAPONE might need stepped on a number of followers’ toes, however for some mere label manufactured non-drama they now have two items debuted in lower than a 12 months. Each being respectably profitable on prime of it.
As a result of, and let me make it clear this isn’t a dig at IS:SUE, I’m simply actual primary comparability numbers – IS:SUE has a lot of floor to make up in an effort to catch as much as ME:I. I can solely hope that each YOU:ME and REBORN (IS:SUE’s fandom identify) will let that little blip go, and stay comparatively supportive of one another going ahead.
With all that being stated, we’re lastly at IS:SUE’s debut, so let’s discuss that. IS:SUE (イッシュ) is made of 4 members. They’re from oldest to youngest, Kenmotsu Nano, Sakaguchi Rino, Tanaka Yuuki, and Aita Rin. On the time of writing, they haven’t introduced any official positions throughout the group. Their identify is meant to imply “a horny and distinctive entity that at all times attracts individuals with its consideration and topicality”. They have been formally introduced as a unit on April twenty fourth 2024, and debuted on June nineteenth 2024 with their single “1st IS:SUE”.
Like earlier than, you possibly can hear together with IS:SUE by way of their Youtube Channel or Official Spotify going ahead. As a result of now I get to dig into my ideas on “1st IS:SUE”.
My normal ideas on “1st IS:SUE” are just like their sister group. Their music appeals to the teenager and early twenty somethings viewers. It’s a part of the tried and true formulation of LAPONE often called “Kpop however make it JPop”. Their styling and theme being far more woman crush in visuals, packaged with the extra trendy traits of Kpop manufacturing. It’s slick, fashionable, and properly put collectively on the technical aspect. IS:SUE is extra prone to garner followers from Kpop as an entire then extra standardized Jpop followers. That being stated to any Kpoppies coming into Jpop by way of IS:SUE – simply know they’re two totally different genres for a purpose. Give your self time to genuinely get to know the Jpop trade earlier than making rash selections.
CONNECT
BIG NOTE: IS:SUE has layered audio tracks on their MV. The English and Korean variations are “radio commentary” type, voiced by Yuuki and Rino respectively. Which could be very inventive however a bit startling in the event you aren’t anticipating it! To listen to “Join” by itself, hit the gear on youtube and click on “audio observe – Japanese unique”.
I hate to start out it this manner however “CONNECT” does something however that. Not less than for me. I’ve spent the higher a part of a month giving this tune an earnest likelihood, and have but to make any constructive connections. To start out, the manufacturing is so poorly dealt with I can barely hear the vocalists. It takes a number of listens to select what they’re singing. The beats are a sizzling mess of just about trending concepts and ideas from SNS, slapped collectively in a clanging, banging, cluttered and directionless mess of a tune. If I used to be extra in-tune with Kpop, I may most likely let you know what teams rejected this tune earlier than LAPONE picked it for IS:SUE.
One in every of my predominate conflicts with this tune, that I often allocate quite a lot of grace for, is the English. “CONNECT”‘s English is rattling close to nonsensical although. In my most beneficiant interpretations, I can simply barely glean what the tune was going for. It’s not notably attention-grabbing or revolutionary, a nasty ass and or woman crush idea, rise from the ashes of being rejected mash up. The group slammed a bunch of English key phrases in for the Japanese viewers to take heed to and go “Oh My God they’re so -cultured- and -international-“. As a local speaker of English, it’s simply actually near absolute drivel.
The nonsensical English can also be coupled with members whose command of English simply isn’t as much as par for this type of factor. Let me be clear, all members have extremely questionable English deliveries tucked in right here. Sadly, the largest offender on this regard, by alternative or by likelihood, is Nano. Her opening traces of “I’d misplaced the sunshine, I’d misplaced the way in which” I couldn’t make heads or tails of for weeks till there was English captioning on the video. Nor her line of “We don’t should be raised up” (1:27), which sounds nearer to “We don’t should be razor-ed” at first hear. She has a very good command for the refrain “Now we lastly join, (Flip it Up), You and I, Heroes-“. That’s a naked minimal right here, however can also be a honest level of aid for me.
Musically, the one redeeming facet of this tune, is the Japanese lyrics and stream. The women of IS:SUE actually can ship once they’re within the zone! When Nano is singing in Japanese, her vocal coloration and supply is completely unmatched. Rino has some impeccable expertise for rapping, which you’ll actually hear at 1:30. She’s no slouch when singing both! Rin’s vocals on the 2:20 have been completely beautiful. I want extra of what was in that 2:20 space had been included all through the tune. It’s a little bit of disgrace that Yuuki bought misplaced on the observe for me, I didn’t have any main stand out moments for her.
It’s additionally clear that quite a lot of effort was put into distinguishing IS:SUE from their sister group. Their styling is rather a lot nearer to my preferences, so I used to be visually extra interested in the group. Their choreography is completely prime notch, and I can see a ton of promise in that facet. It’s clear to me that LAPONE GIRLS is giving IS:SUE the price range as properly, between the inexperienced display screen scenes, set areas and CGI being included. Nevertheless just like the tune, the execution is cluttered and directionless. It feels extra like a collage of bad-ass stuff, verses a cohesive debut idea.
STATIC
I’m going to be sincere right here, it’s not honest to essentially discuss “STATIC” at this level. I haven’t almost had the identical period of time to hear by it like “CONNECT”. So I’ll be aware, that I’m giving this observe much more grace then the A-side to make up for it. I’ll additionally readily admit my emotions have modified rather a lot in a really brief period of time anyway.
I’m actually a bit shocked that “CONNECT” and “STATIC” have been written and produced kind of by the identical lyricists and composers. They honestly really feel like two utterly totally different songs. My real first impression was that this too was one other observe that had clearly been written for a Kpop group, rejected sufficient occasions and ended up in IS:SUE’s arms. It had quite a lot of tonal whiplash because it contrasts so closely to “CONNECT”. I used to be struggling to determine how they match collectively, in the event that they have been suppose to in any respect.
Upon extra re-listenings, I spotted that “STATIC” because it opened, jogged my memory of boy group Snow Man’s observe “Colour Me Alive”. That’s fairly the massive praise in my e-book. One other level I famous was that very similar to ME:I’s “Sugar Bomb”, “STATIC” was sticking with me as their superior sound. It’s a little bit of an odd set of coincidences, however I truly discover it fairly charming for each teams.
“STATIC” has comparable points to “CONNECT”, the manufacturing nonetheless overpowers the members’ vocals at occasions. It feels like a pair totally different songs cobbled collectively too. It’s considerably much less in your face although, and comes off as somewhat dreamy making it simpler on the ear.
That is additionally the tune have been you possibly can genuinely hear why these ladies have been picked up for IS:SUE. Rino completely shines in her deliveries in right here. I completely get shivers once I hear Rino’s supply pre-chorus at forty-nine seconds in with “君の声がしたから” and once more at 1:38 with “解けないように、この心だけは…” is completely attractive. Nano’s voice compliments Rino so properly, particularly of their opening exchanges. Rin’s voice provides such a youthful however not infantile air of caprice to the observe as properly. Yuuki’s supply jogs my memory of a number of totally different voices in Kpop, in a great way, that basically steers the observe in direction of what IS:SUE clearly needs to perform. The English, the bane of my existence for IS:SUE it appears, is considerably extra palpable right here particularly with Yuuki’s supply. I’m genuinely impressed on the 180 in execution.
Lyrically, this tune is far more cohesive and it’s genuinely grown on me. I adopted the offered lyric translations of the above video only for reference. I additionally agree with the way it was translated and interpreted which helps. “STATIC” in my e-book is the gold star commonplace for what “Kpop however make it Jpop” ought to sound like. It’s extremely good in my humble opinion. The ultimate little bit of icing on the cake is that the dance that goes with it’s completely fabulous too.
Total, I’m having some points with IS:SUE’s debut. I’m not stunned that their administration selected “CONNECT” as their a-side. As an off-the-cuff fan, I simply suppose it was the improper option to have one thing so jarring and disjointed be their debut single. I do perceive that it has the a-side formulation to it, therefore it being picked. “STATIC” for me will at all times stay the superior tune. It simply doesn’t fairly have the formulation to be a-side materials, however because the b-side is extremely promising.
I do really feel vindicated now that these girls, Nano, Rino, Yuuki and Rin have debuted. They have been all, some extra then others, robbed of a spot or highlight in PD 101 in my humble opinion. I’m glad LAPONE didn’t waste time between trainee period and debut, since this was one of many extra well timed debuts I’ve seen in awhile. I’m simply particularly blissful for Rino since she is simply too gifted to not be hear by the world.
I’m a bit conflicted going ahead. IS:SUE’s debut was extremely lopsided for me. I don’t suppose I’ll be committing to the fandom identify of REBORN simply but. Nevertheless, I shall be protecting unfastened tabs on IS:SUE going ahead and seeing what they do sooner or later. If it’s extra in-tune to “STATIC” think about me sat. However I’d like to know what you guys suppose, so be sure you drop your emotions and opinions down beneath!
FOLLOW IS:SUE
